How to Start a Loyalty Program on Shopify (And Why It Matters)

How to Start a Loyalty Program on Shopify (And Why It Matters)

In a world full of options, keeping customers loyal is no small task. That’s where a loyalty program comes in—it’s a straightforward way to turn one-time shoppers into returning fans.

For Shopify stores, loyalty programs offer an affordable strategy to keep your brand in customers’ minds, build connections, and encourage repeat purchases.

In this guide, we’ll walk through the benefits of loyalty programs and the steps to setting one up on Shopify. Ready to make your store their favorite? Let’s get started.

Why Your Shopify Store Needs a Loyalty Program

Ever wonder why some brands seem to have a loyal following that keeps coming back? It’s not just their products—it’s how they make customers feel appreciated.

That’s where a loyalty program can work wonders for your Shopify store. A loyalty program is more than just a nice extra; it’s a way to build lasting relationships that make customers feel connected to your brand. Here’s a closer look at why it matters.

1. Keeps Customers Coming Back for More

Let’s be real: customer loyalty is hard to come by. But a well-thought-out loyalty program can encourage shoppers to return, offering them something to look forward to each time they visit.

By rewarding points or perks for each purchase, you’re building a relationship that goes beyond a one-time sale. Customers start to see value in sticking with your brand, knowing they’re working towards something rewarding each time they shop.

2. Gives Shoppers a Reason to Spend More

Loyalty programs are great for nudging customers to add a little extra to their cart. When customers see that spending just a bit more can earn them extra points or rewards, it’s a win-win.

For example, setting up rewards for reaching certain spending milestones can make customers think, “Just one more item and I’ll earn those bonus points!” It’s these subtle motivations that can increase average order value without feeling like a pushy upsell.

3. Turns Shoppers into Brand Advocates

The best loyalty programs make customers feel like they’re part of something special, and when people feel valued, they’re more likely to spread the word. If your customers love the perks they get, they’re naturally more inclined to tell their friends or share their experience online.

Essentially, a good loyalty program can create a small community of brand advocates who promote your store simply because they’re happy with what they’re getting.

4. Helps You Stand Out from the Crowd

Let’s face it, the online shopping world is crowded. A loyalty program can be that unique edge that makes your store stand out. When customers compare similar products from different stores, having a loyalty program can be the deciding factor.

It shows customers that you’re not just in it for a quick sale; you’re here to build a long-term relationship with them. And in an age where brand loyalty can feel rare, that’s a big advantage.

In a nutshell, a loyalty program is more than a rewards system—it’s a way to connect with customers, keep them coming back, and make them feel genuinely valued.

For Shopify store owners, it’s a powerful tool for building a loyal customer base and driving consistent sales over time.

Different Types of Loyalty Programs for Shopify Stores

Setting up a loyalty program might feel overwhelming, but the good news is there’s no one-size-fits-all approach.

Shopify store owners can choose from a range of loyalty program types, each with its own way of encouraging customers to return, spend more, and even share their experience with others. Here are some of the most popular types of loyalty programs to consider:

1. Points-Based Programs

How It Works: Customers earn points for every purchase they make. These points can later be redeemed for discounts, free products, or other rewards.

Why It’s Effective: It’s straightforward and familiar—customers know the drill. The more they spend, the more points they earn, making them feel rewarded each time they shop. Points-based programs are great for building engagement and encouraging repeat purchases without requiring big discounts.

2. Tiered Programs

How It Works: Tiered programs reward customers based on their level of engagement. For example, you could offer Bronze, Silver, and Gold tiers, with each level offering progressively better perks, such as bigger discounts or early access to sales.

Why It’s Effective: This structure motivates customers to increase their loyalty to unlock higher-tier benefits. It adds an element of exclusivity that makes customers want to stick around to see what rewards they can earn next.

3. Referral Programs

How It Works: Customers earn rewards by referring friends or family members to your store. When someone they refer makes a purchase, both the customer and the new shopper receive a benefit, such as a discount or bonus points.

Why It’s Effective: Word-of-mouth marketing is powerful, and referral programs encourage loyal customers to bring in new ones. It’s a way to expand your customer base organically, with each referral strengthening your brand’s reach.

4. Exclusive Perks for VIP Members

How It Works: VIP loyalty programs focus on rewarding the most dedicated customers with exclusive benefits, like early access to new products, member-only discounts, or invites to special events.

Why It’s Effective: VIP perks make customers feel valued and part of an exclusive community, which can enhance brand loyalty and make them more likely to engage with your store consistently. It’s particularly effective for brands with high levels of repeat customers.

5. Spend-Based Rewards

How It Works: In spend-based loyalty programs, customers earn rewards based on how much they spend, rather than the number of purchases. For example, for every $100 spent, they might receive a $10 reward or discount.

Why It’s Effective: Spend-based rewards incentivize higher order values, making it a good choice for stores looking to increase average transaction sizes. It also rewards loyal customers who make larger purchases, giving them a reason to choose your store over competitors.

Choosing the right loyalty program for your Shopify store comes down to understanding your customers and what motivates them. Whether it’s points, tiers, referrals, or exclusive perks, there’s a loyalty program style that can fit your brand and make customers feel excited to shop with you again.

Steps to Creating a Loyalty Program on Shopify

Starting a loyalty program on Shopify may sound like a big task, but it’s manageable when broken down into clear steps.

Here’s a straightforward guide to help you set up a loyalty program that’s both effective and easy for customers to engage with.

Step 1: Define Your Goals

Why It Matters: Knowing what you want out of your loyalty program will guide every decision you make. Are you looking to increase repeat purchases, boost average order value, or turn customers into brand advocates?

How to Do It: Write down specific goals for the program. For example, “Increase repeat purchases by 20% in six months” or “Drive 15% more referrals within a year.” Clear goals will help you measure success and adjust as needed.

Step 2: Choose a Loyalty Program Model

Why It Matters: Each type of loyalty program has its strengths, and the right model depends on your customer base. For example, points-based programs work well for stores with frequent purchases, while referral programs can help expand your customer base.

How to Do It: Review the program types (points-based, tiered, referral, VIP, etc.) and choose the one that best aligns with your goals and customer behavior. Consider what will excite your customers most and drive engagement.

Step 3: Select the Right Loyalty App for Shopify

Why It Matters: Shopify has several loyalty program apps that simplify setup and management. Choosing the right one can save time and give you the tools to track and optimize your program.

How to Do It: Look into popular loyalty apps like Smile.io, LoyaltyLion, and Yotpo. Each offers different features, such as points tracking, customizable rewards, and integration with marketing tools. Choose an app that fits your budget and program goals, and that offers an intuitive user experience.

Step 4: Set Up Your Rewards Structure

Why It Matters: The rewards structure is the heart of your loyalty program. It’s what will keep customers engaged and encourage them to come back. Make sure the rewards are attractive and attainable, but not too easy to reach.

How to Do It: Decide on the rewards and how customers will earn them. For example, you could offer 1 point per dollar spent, with 100 points equaling a $10 discount. Think about offering rewards for non-purchase actions too, like signing up for an account, sharing on social media, or referring friends.

Step 5: Customize the Look and Feel of Your Program

Why It Matters: Branding matters! A well-designed loyalty program that matches your store’s look and feel makes the program feel like a natural part of your brand, rather than an afterthought.

How to Do It: Use the customization options in your loyalty app to add your brand’s colors, logo, and unique program name. If possible, create a simple landing page explaining the program details to make it easy for customers to understand how it works.

Step 6: Promote Your Loyalty Program

Why It Matters: Even the best loyalty program won’t work if customers don’t know about it. Promoting the program ensures your customers are aware of the perks waiting for them.

How to Do It: Announce the program via email marketing, social media, and on-site banners. Highlight the rewards on your homepage, product pages, and checkout page. You might also consider adding a small pop-up on your website to introduce new visitors to the program.

By following these steps, you’ll have a loyalty program on Shopify that’s both easy for customers to engage with and valuable for your business.

A well-structured program can be a long-term asset, helping you build a loyal customer base and generate repeat sales.

Best Shopify Loyalty Apps to Get Started

Choosing the right loyalty app is key to making your program work smoothly on Shopify.

These apps simplify the setup and management process, offer a range of customization options, and allow you to track how well your program is performing.

Here are some of the top loyalty apps for Shopify, each with unique features to suit different needs and budgets:

1. Smile.io

Smile.io
  • Why It’s Great: Smile.io is one of the most popular loyalty apps for Shopify, known for its user-friendly interface and flexibility. It offers points-based, referral, and VIP programs, letting you build a multi-tiered loyalty experience.
  • Top Features: Easy points and rewards tracking, customizable rewards, integrations with email marketing tools, and a clean interface that matches most store designs.
  • Best For: Small to medium-sized stores looking for an affordable, flexible loyalty solution.

2. LoyaltyLion

LoyaltyLion
  • Why It’s Great: LoyaltyLion is a highly customizable app, perfect for stores that want more control over their loyalty program’s branding and functionality. It integrates with other Shopify apps, making it easy to build a comprehensive rewards system.
  • Top Features: Advanced customization options, multi-language support, detailed analytics, and integrations with email and on-site messaging.
  • Best For: Growing Shopify stores with a focus on brand customization and a budget for premium features.

3. Yotpo

Yotpo
  • Why It’s Great: Yotpo is known for its suite of customer engagement tools, including loyalty, reviews, and referrals. It’s ideal for stores looking to combine a rewards program with customer reviews and user-generated content to boost credibility.
  • Top Features: Integrated reviews and loyalty features, flexible rewards structure, social media integrations, and easy-to-manage referral programs.
  • Best For: Stores that want an all-in-one solution for loyalty, reviews, and referrals to enhance customer trust.

4. ReferralCandy

ReferralCandy
  • Why It’s Great: ReferralCandy is focused solely on referral programs, making it a solid choice for stores that want to encourage customers to bring in friends and family. The app makes it easy to set up simple referral rewards that motivate customers to spread the word.
  • Top Features: Straightforward referral tracking, customizable rewards, automated emails for referrals, and analytics to measure referral success.
  • Best For: Shopify stores looking specifically to grow through customer referrals without adding a complex loyalty program.

5. Growave

Growave
  • Why It’s Great: Growave offers a wide range of features in a single app, including wish lists, product reviews, social media logins, and loyalty programs. It’s a budget-friendly option for stores that want multiple engagement features without using multiple apps.
  • Top Features: Points-based rewards, customer reviews, wish lists, and integrations with email marketing.
  • Best For: Small to medium-sized stores that want to keep things simple with one app handling multiple features.

Each of these apps offers different strengths, so it’s worth considering which features matter most to your store and customers.

Whether it’s points, referrals, or a VIP experience, choosing the right app makes managing your Shopify loyalty program a lot easier—and lets you focus on connecting with customers and building brand loyalty.

Tips for Making Your Loyalty Program Successful

Launching a loyalty program is only the first step. To really make it work, you’ll need a few tricks up your sleeve to keep customers engaged and excited about your rewards.

Here are some tried-and-true tips for creating a loyalty program that customers actually want to participate in:

1. Keep the Program Simple and Clear

Why It Matters: If your customers don’t understand how to earn or redeem rewards, they’re unlikely to engage with the program. A complicated structure can be a big turn-off, so keep things straightforward.

How to Do It: Make earning and redeeming rewards easy to understand. Use simple language and include a short explanation on your website or app. For example, “Earn 1 point for every dollar spent, redeem 100 points for $10 off.”

2. Reward More Than Just Purchases

Why It Matters: Customers love feeling appreciated, even when they’re not shopping. By rewarding activities beyond purchases, you give them more ways to engage with your brand and earn rewards.

How to Do It: Offer points for signing up, writing product reviews, following your social media accounts, or referring friends. This multi-angle approach keeps your customers involved with your brand, even between purchases.

3. Promote the Program Everywhere

Why It Matters: Even the best loyalty program won’t succeed if people don’t know about it. Customers should be reminded of the program whenever they interact with your brand.

How to Do It: Announce the program on your website, send an email to your subscribers, post about it on social media, and mention it during checkout. A small pop-up or banner highlighting the loyalty program can help introduce new visitors to the rewards they could earn.

4. Offer Exclusive Perks to Keep Customers Engaged

Why It Matters: Customers love exclusivity, and offering special perks makes loyalty members feel valued. Exclusive benefits can encourage them to keep coming back for more.

How to Do It: Consider adding VIP rewards like early access to sales, members-only discounts, or first looks at new products. These perks make customers feel like they’re part of an exclusive community and can increase program participation.

5. Ask for Feedback and Make Improvements

Why It Matters: Your customers are the best source of insights for improving your loyalty program. Their feedback can help you tweak the program to better fit their needs and expectations.

How to Do It: Send a short survey or ask for feedback through email, especially to frequent participants. Use this feedback to make adjustments, whether it’s adding new reward options, simplifying the earning process, or improving the user experience.

6. Track Performance and Make Data-Driven Adjustments

Why It Matters: Regularly analyzing your loyalty program’s performance helps you understand what’s working and what could use improvement. Metrics like repeat purchase rates, engagement levels, and redemption rates provide valuable insights.

How to Do It: Use your loyalty app’s analytics to track key metrics. If certain rewards aren’t popular, consider replacing them. If engagement is low, adjust the reward structure or boost promotion efforts. Constant tweaking helps keep your program effective and appealing.

By focusing on these tips, you can ensure your loyalty program stays relevant and valuable to your customers.

A well-executed program not only keeps customers engaged but also builds long-term relationships that can lead to steady growth for your Shopify store.

Measuring the Success of Your Loyalty Program

A loyalty program is a long-term investment in your Shopify store’s growth, so tracking its performance is essential to know if it’s truly driving results.

By monitoring the right metrics, you can get a clear picture of what’s working, what isn’t, and where you can make improvements. Here are some key metrics to measure the success of your loyalty program:

1. Customer Retention Rate

Why It Matters: Retention rate shows you the percentage of customers who keep coming back to your store over time. A high retention rate suggests that your loyalty program is effective at building long-term relationships.

How to Measure: Track the number of repeat customers over a given period and compare it to the previous periods to see if your loyalty program is increasing retention.

2. Average Order Value (AOV)

Why It Matters: Loyalty programs often encourage customers to spend more per order, especially if rewards are based on spending thresholds. Monitoring AOV can help you see if your program is influencing customers to add more to their carts.

How to Measure: Calculate the AOV by dividing total revenue by the number of orders. Compare the AOV of loyalty members vs. non-members to see the impact of your program.

3. Customer Lifetime Value (CLTV)

Why It Matters: CLTV represents the total revenue you can expect from a single customer over their relationship with your brand. A higher CLTV means your loyalty program is successfully driving long-term customer value.

How to Measure: CLTV can be calculated by multiplying the AOV by the average purchase frequency and the customer lifespan. Use your loyalty app or Shopify’s analytics tools to track CLTV over time.

4. Program Engagement Rate

Why It Matters: Engagement rate shows how actively customers are participating in your loyalty program. High engagement means customers find value in your rewards, while low engagement suggests it may be time to adjust the program structure or rewards.

How to Measure: Track metrics like points earned, rewards redeemed, and referral activity. A good loyalty app should provide these insights, giving you a breakdown of how customers are interacting with the program.

5. Redemption Rate

Why It Matters: The redemption rate shows how often customers redeem their rewards. A low redemption rate could mean that rewards aren’t enticing enough, while a high rate suggests that customers see value in the program.

How to Measure: Divide the number of rewards redeemed by the total rewards earned. Adjust the rewards structure if you see low redemption to make it easier or more appealing for customers to claim their points.

6. Referral and Social Shares

Why It Matters: If you have a referral element in your loyalty program, tracking how often customers refer others or share your brand on social media can reveal the program’s word-of-mouth impact.

How to Measure: Look at referral sign-ups and social shares through your app analytics. If referrals are low, consider adding more attractive referral rewards or promoting the referral program more actively.

7. Feedback and Reviews

Why It Matters: Customer feedback is invaluable for understanding the strengths and weaknesses of your loyalty program. Direct input from customers can highlight areas that need improvement and help shape future adjustments.

How to Measure: Collect feedback through surveys, reviews, or directly within the loyalty app. Listen to what customers enjoy and what they’d like to see improved, and make changes accordingly.

By keeping an eye on these metrics, you’ll be able to assess the real impact of your loyalty program. If certain areas aren’t performing as expected, don’t hesitate to tweak the program to better fit your customers’ needs.

A well-maintained loyalty program can be a powerful tool for driving repeat business, increasing order values, and building a community around your Shopify store.

Start Building Customer Loyalty Today

A loyalty program is more than just a strategy—it’s a way to show customers that you value their support and want them to be part of your brand’s journey.

For Shopify store owners, a well-designed loyalty program can turn occasional shoppers into dedicated fans, increase repeat sales, and create a community around your brand.

Starting a loyalty program doesn’t have to be complicated. By choosing a simple model, using a reliable Shopify loyalty app, and regularly refining the program based on customer feedback, you’ll have a loyalty program that feels authentic and engaging.

Whether you’re just getting started or looking to optimize an existing program, remember that loyalty programs are a long-term investment in your customer relationships.

Take that first step, build a program that reflects your brand, and start turning everyday transactions into lasting connections.

Back to blog